Reform of Research Evaluation in UK University, Research Excellence Framework and Its Application
Wu Yong1,Xia Wenjuan1,Zhu Weidong2,Wang Lina3
1.School of Management,Hefei University of Technology,Hefei 230009,China;
2.School of Economics, Hefei University of Technology,Hefei 230061,China;
3.Institute of Science and Technology, Hefei University of Technology,Hefei 230009,China
Abstract：As a model of global research evaluation,UK universities have implemented seven large-scale research quality assessments since the 1980s.The increasingly perfect research evaluation system has greatly enhanced the scientific influence and international competitiveness of British universities.This article makes an in-depth discussion on the institutional logic of the reform of the research evaluation system from RAE(2008)to REF(2014)in higher education and systematically discusses the evaluation organizational patterns,evaluation indicators and specific contents of REF(2014).At the same time,we establish a quantitative calculation model and analyze the mainstream quality-related research funding model based on REF assessment results.Researches can provide useful experience for the reform of research assessment in Chinese universities.
吴勇,夏文娟,朱卫东,王丽娜. 英国高校科研评估改革、科研卓越框架及其应用[J]. 中国科技论坛, 2019(2): 160-168.
Wu Yong,Xia Wenjuan,Zhu Weidong,Wang Lina. Reform of Research Evaluation in UK University, Research Excellence Framework and Its Application. , 2019(2): 160-168.
[1] 刘莉.英国大学科研评价改革:从RAE到REF[J] .科学学与科学技术管理,2014(2):39-45.
[2] Research Excellence Framework 2014:The Results[EB/OL] .(2014-12-18)[2018-02-05] .http://www.ref.ac.uk/2014/pubs/201401/.
[3] 杨卫.规为引擎 法为准绳——引领中国基础研究进入新常态[J] .中国科学基金,2015(1):5-10.
[4] 伍莺莺,张昭.英国科研评价体系探析及其启示[J] .科技进步与对策,2016,33(12):138-142.
[5] 蒋林浩,沈文钦,陈洪捷,等.学科评估的方法、指标体系及其政策影响:美英中三国的比较研究[J] .高等教育研究,2014(11):92-101.
[6] 刘兴凯,左小娟.基于卓越框架(REF)的英国大学科研质量拨款模式及其启示[J] .大连理工大学学报(社会科学版),2016,37(3):6-11.
[7] 刘芳,张晨,朱卫东,等.中英高校科研经费成本管理比较研究[J] .科技管理研究,2016,36(3):61-65.
[8] 张树良,张志强,王雪梅.国际科研评价体系现存问题及发展新趋势分析[J] .科学学研究,2015,33(8):1127-1133.
[9] DEARLOVE J.The deadly dull issue of university “administration”?Good governance,managerialism and organising academic work[J] .Higher education policy,1998,11(1):59-79.
[10] NOORDEN R V.A profusion of measures[J] .Nature,2010,465:864-865.
[11] DE J S,BARKER K,COX D,et al.Understanding societal impact through productive interactions:ICT research as a case[J] .Research evaluation,2015,23(2):89-102.
[12] HINRICHS S,GRANT J.A new resource for identifying and assessing the impacts of research[J] .BMC medicine,2015,13(1):148.
[13] 刘兴凯,梁珣.英国高校科研评估的制度改革、效应及其借鉴意义[J] .清华大学教育研究,2015(3):82-88.
[14] GOULD T H P.The church and peer review:was peer review fairer,more honest then than now[J] .Journal of scholarly publishing,2012,44(1):36-60.
[15] Report on the pilot exercise to develop bibliometric indicators for the Research Excellence Framework[EB/OL] .(2009-09-01)[2018-02-05] .http://www.hefce.ac.uk/data/year/2009/Report on the pilot exercise to develop bibliometric indicators for the Research Excellence Framework /.
[16] BRINN T,JONES M,PENDLEBURY M.Why do UK accounting and finance academics not publish in top US journals[J] .British accounting review,2001,33(2):223-232.
[17] ROBIN Middlehurst.Quality enhancement for accountability and transformation:a framework for the future[J] .Tertiary education & management,1997,3(1):15-24.
[18] Guide to funding 2015-16 How HEFCE allocates its funds[EB/OL] .(2015-03-25)[2018-02-05] .http://www.hefce.ac.uk/pubs/year/2015/201504/.
[19] 张晓军,席酉民.我国高校科研管理的问题与改革建议——基于资源配置的视角[J] .科学学与科学技术管理,2011,32(7):58-63.
2019, 
