Pressure System,Political Mobility and the TTFS Diffusion ——An Event History Analysis of 208 Prefecture-Level Cities in China
Xi Hu1, Wang Yanxia2
1. School of Public Management,Huazhong University of Science and Technology,Wuhan 430074,China; 2. College of State Governance,Southwest University,Chongqing 400715,China
Abstract：The Technical Task Force System (TTFS)is an important underpinning for implementing the strategy of rural revitalization and three rural issues.The diffusion mechanisms of the institution from 1999 to 2016,however,have not been explored adequately.We tested the effects of pressure system and political mobility on the TTFS in 208 prefecture-level cities of China,by applying the traditional event history analysis.Our research provided the evidence that,provincial regulations,inside-provincial competition,and public opinion pressure,had significant positive effect on the adoption in prefecture-level cities.And,political mobility of party secretaries and mayors in prefecture-level cities,had no significant effect.
席虎, 汪艳霞. 压力型体制、官员流动与科技特派员制度扩散——面向208个地级市的事件史分析[J]. 中国科技论坛, 2022(11): 35-44.
Xi Hu, Wang Yanxia. Pressure System,Political Mobility and the TTFS Diffusion ——An Event History Analysis of 208 Prefecture-Level Cities in China. , 2022(11): 35-44.
[1]WALKER J L.The diffusion of innovations among the American states[J].American political science review,1969,63 (3):880-899. [2]SHIPAN C R,VOLDEN C.The mechanisms of policy diffusion[J].American journal of political science,2008,52 (4):840-857. [3]MA L.The diffusion of government microblogging:evidence from Chinese municipal police bureaus[J].Public management review,2013,15 (2):288-309. [4]ZHANG Y,ZHU X.Multiple mechanisms of policy diffusion in China[J].Public management review,2019,21 (4):495-514. [5]SUGIYAMA N B.Bottom-up policy diffusion:national emulation of a conditional cash transfer program in Brazil[J].Publius:the journal of federalism,2012,42 (1):25-51. [6]MA L.Site visits,policy learning,and the diffusion of policy innovation:evidence from public bicycle programs in China[J].Journal of Chinese political science,2017,22 (4):581-599. [7]MAKSE T,VOLDEN C.The role of policy attributes in the diffusion of innovations[J].The journal of politics,2011,73 (1):108-124. [8]GARRETT K N,JANSA J M.Interest group influence in policy diffusion networks[J].State politics & policy quarterly,2015,15 (3):387-417. [9]MILLER S M,NICHOLSON-CROTTY J,NICHOLSON-CROTTY S.The consequences of legislative term limits for policy diffusion[J].Political research quarterly,2018,71 (3):573-585. [10]GILARDI F.Four ways we can improve policy diffusion research[J].State politics & policy quarterly,2016,16 (1):8-21. [11]XU C.The fundamental institutions of China's reforms and development[J].Journal of economic literature,2011,49 (4):1076-1151. [12]张闫龙.城市基础设施领域公私合作政策的扩散[J].公共行政评论,2015 (3):25-50. [13]朱多刚,郭俊华.专利资助政策的创新与扩散:面向中国省份的事件史分析[J].公共行政评论,2016 (5):64-83. [14]ZHU X,ZHAO H.Recognition of innovation and diffusion of welfare policy:alleviating urban poverty in Chinese cities during fiscal recentralization[J].Governance,2018,31 (4),721-739. [15]王洛忠,庞锐.中国公共政策时空演进机理及扩散路径:以河长制的落地与变迁为例[J].中国行政管理,2018 (5):63-69. [16]ZHU X,ZHANG Y.Political mobility and dynamic diffusion of innovation:the spread of municipal pro-business administrative reform in China[J].Journal of public administration research and theory,2016,26 (3),535-551. [17]SHIPAN C R,VOLDEN C.Bottom-up federalism:the diffusion of antismoking policies from US cities to states[J].American journal of political science,2006,50 (4),825-843. [18]杨雪冬.压力型体制:一个概念的简明史[J].社会科学,2012 (11):4-12. [19]CHOI E K.Patronage and performance:factors in the political mobility of provincial leaders in post-Deng China[J].The China quarterly,2012 (212):965-981. [20]张楠,卢洪友.官员垂直交流与环境治理——来自中国109个城市市委书记 (市长)的经验证据[J].公共管理学报,2016 (1):31-43. [21]檀学文.宁夏科技特派员制度的机制与效果[J].中国农村经济,2007 (4):60-68. [22]李媛媛,陈国申.从 “放权”到 “收权”: “简政放权”的怪圈—— “莱芜经验”的反思[J].社会主义研究,2005 (5):60-62. [23]黄季焜,胡瑞法,孙振玉.让科学技术进入农村的千家万户——建立新的农业技术推广创新体系[J].农业经济问题,2000 (4):17-25. [24]朱旭峰,张友浪.地方政府创新经验推广的难点何在——公共政策创新扩散理论的研究评述[J].人民论坛·学术前沿,2014 (17):63-77. [25]荣敬本. “压力型体制”研究的回顾[J].经济社会体制比较,2013 (6):1-3. [26]周雪光.基层政府间的 “共谋现象”:一个政府行为的制度逻辑[J].社会学研究,2008 (6):1-21. [27]荣敬本,崔之元,王拴正,等.从压力型体制向民主合作体制的转变:县乡两级政治体制改革[M].北京:中央编译出版社,1998. [28]陈水生.从压力型体制到督办责任体制:中国国家现代化导向下政府运作模式的转型与机制创新[J].行政论坛,2017 (5):16-23. [29]渠敬东,周飞舟,应星.从总体支配到技术治理——基于中国30年改革经验的社会学分析[J].中国社会科学,2009 (6):104-127. [30]张翔.基层政策执行的 “共识式变通”:一个组织学解释——基于市场监管系统上下级互动过程的观察[J].公共管理学报,2019 (4):1-11. [31]冉冉. “压力型体制”下的政治激励与地方环境治理[J].经济社会体制比较,2013 (3):111-118. [32]KOSTKA G,NAHM J.Central-local relations:recentralization and environmental governance in China[J].The China quarterly,2017,231:567-582. [33]王诗宗,杨帆.基层政策执行中的调适性社会动员:行政控制与多元参与[J].中国社会科学,2018 (11):135-155. [34]MINTROM M.Policy entrepreneurs and the diffusion of innovation[J].American journal of political science,1997,27 (3):738-770. [35]BERRY F S,FLOWERS G.Public entrepreneurs in the policy process:performance-based budgeting reform in Florida[J].Journal of public budgeting,accounting & financial management,1999,11 (4):578-617. [36]ZHU X.Policy change and expert involvement in China[J].Public administration,2013,91 (2):281-302. [37]DAMANPOUR F,SCHNEIDER M.Characteristics of innovation and innovation adoption in public organizations:assessing the role of managers[J].Journal of public administration research and theory,2009,19 (3):495-522. [38]YI H,BERRY F S,CHEN W.Management innovation and policy diffusion through leadership transfer networks:an agent network diffusion model[J].Journal of public administration research and theory,2018,28 (4):457-474. [39]HUANG Y.Managing Chinese bureaucrats:an institutional economics perspective[J].Political studies,2002,50 (1):61-79. [40]YI H,CHEN W.Portable innovation,policy wormholes,and innovation diffusion[J].Public administration review,2019,79 (5):737-748. [41]周雪光.从 “官吏分途”到 “层级分流”:帝国逻辑下的中国官僚人事制度[J].社会,2016 (1):1-33. [42]ZHU X.Executive entrepreneurship,career mobility and the transfer of policy paradigms[J].Journal of comparative policy analysis:research and practice,2018,20 (4):354-369. [43]何艳玲.好研究是当下公共管理研究的大问题——兼论 “中国”作为方法论[J].中国行政管理,2020 (4):56-63. [44]JENSEN J L.A multipopulation comparison of the diffusion of public organizations and policies across space and time[J].Policy studies journal,2004,32 (1):109-127. [45]庞明礼.领导高度重视:一种科层运作的注意力分配方式[J].中国行政管理,2019 (4):93-99. [46]GRAY V.Innovation in the states:a diffusion study[J].American political science review,1973,67 (4):1174-1185. [47]BERRY F S,BERRY W D.Tax innovation in the states:capitalizing on political opportunity[J].American journal of political science,1992,36 (3):715-742. [48]BERRY F S,BERRY W D.State lottery adoptions as policy innovations:an event history analysis[J].American political science review,1990,84 (2):395-415. [49]BALLA S J.Interstate professional associations and the diffusion of policy innovations[J].American politics research,2001,29 (3):221-245. [50]马亮.公共服务创新的扩散:中国城市公共自行车计划的实证分析[J].公共行政评论,2015 (3):51-78. [51]周黎安.中国地方官员的晋升锦标赛模式研究[J].经济研究,2007 (7):36-50. [52]马亮.官员晋升激励与政府绩效目标设置——中国省级面板数据的实证研究[J].公共管理学报,2013 (2):28-39. [53]黄安胜,章子豪,朱春奎.中国科技特派员制度的扩散分析——基于省际扩散的实证[J].软科学,2020 (11):14-20. [54]周雪光,艾云,葛建华,等.中国地方政府官员的空间流动:层级分流模式与经验证据[J].社会,2018 (3):1-45. [55]陈思丞.政府条块差异与纵向创新扩散[J].社会学研究,2020 (2):146-169. [56]练宏.注意力竞争——基于参与观察与多案例的组织学分析[J].社会学研究,2016 (4):1-26.
2022, 
