Analysis of the Government's Role in the National Innovation System from the System Perspective——Summary of Innovation Practice Based on the United States and Japan
Yan Jinmei1, Liu Jiejiao2
1. University of Chinese Academy of Social Sciences,Beijing 102488,China; 2. Institute of Industrial Economics of CASS,Beijing 100006,China
Abstract：Taking the system characteristics such as the purpose,integrity,dynamic relevance,emergence and openness in the national innovation system (NIS)as a starting point,combining with the relevant practical experience of the US and Japan,this article analyzes the role of the government in the NIS.The research shows that in the NIS the government is not only to repair failures,but also to lead the entire system.The government's leading and active role in the NIS is mainly manifested in the following aspects:formulating innovation strategies to guide the direction of innovation;improving the input of innovation elements to consolidate innovation infrastructure;encouraging innovation entities to awaken innovation vitality;coordinating innovation activities to improve innovation efficiency;strengthening intellectual property protection and building an innovation culture to create a good innovation environment;funding innovation in key areas to promote the emergence of multiple innovations;promoting open innovation to introduce global high-quality innovation resources.
严锦梅, 刘戒骄. 系统视角下国家创新体系中的政府作用——基于美国和日本的创新实践综述[J]. 中国科技论坛, 2022(2): 50-58.
Yan Jinmei, Liu Jiejiao. Analysis of the Government's Role in the National Innovation System from the System Perspective——Summary of Innovation Practice Based on the United States and Japan. , 2022(2): 50-58.
[1]ANDERSSON U,DASI A,MUDAMBI R,et al.Technology,innovation and knowledge:the importance of ideas and international connectivity[J].Journal of world business,2016,51 (1):153-162. [2]METCALFE S,RAMLOGAN R.Innovation systems and the competitive process in developing economies[J].Quarterly review of economics and finance,2008 (48):433-446. [3]FREEMAN C.Technology policy and economic performance:lessons from Japan[M].London:Pinter Publishers,1987. [4]LUNDVALL B A.National innovation systems:towards a theory of innovation and interactive learning [M].London:Pinter Publishers,1992. [5]NELSON R R.National innovation systems:a comparative analysis[M].Oxford:Oxford University Press,1993. [6]PATEL P,PAVITT K.The nature and economic importance of national innovation systems[J].STI review,1994(14):9-32. [7]EDQUIST C.Systems of innovation:technologies,institutions and organizations [M].London:Psychology Press,1997. [8]OECD.National innovation systems[R].Paris:OECD,1997. [9]查米纳德,伦德瓦尔,哈尼夫.国家创新体系概论[M].上海市科学学研究所,译.上海:上海交通大学出版社,2019. [10]辜胜阻,洪群联.创新型国家建设的战略思考[J].经济管理,2008 (19-20):1-6. [11]陈继勇,余罡.发达国家与新兴经济体政府在国家创新体系建设中的实践及启示[J].理论月刊,2011 (10):142-144. [12]王德华,刘戒骄.国家创新系统中政府作用分析[J].经济与管理研究,2015,36 (4):31-38. [13]陈劲.关于构建新型国家创新体系的思考[J].中国科学院院刊,2018,33 (5):479-483. [14]贺德方,唐玉立,周华东.科技创新政策体系构建及实践[J].科学学研究,2019,37 (1):3-10,44. [15]MAZZUCATO M.Form market fixing to market-creating:a new framework for innovation policy[J].Industry and innovation,2016 (23):140-156. [16]SCHOT J,STEINMUELLER W E.Transformative change:what role for science,technology and innovation policy[J].Research policy,2019,48 (4):843-848. [17]玛丽安娜·马祖卡托.创新型政府:构建公共与私人部门的共生共赢关系[M].李磊,束东新,程单剑,等译.北京:中信出版集团股份有限公司,2019. [18]SUSENO Y,STANDING C.The systems perspective of national innovation ecosystems[J].Systems research and behavioral science,2018,35 (3):282-307. [19]崔新健,章东明.国家创新系统的开放性研究[J].中国科技论坛,2016 (6):5-10. [20]王开阳,沈华,陈锐.国家创新系统中的连接性政策:概念与应用[J].科学学研究,2018,36 (3):418-424,445. [21]顾培亮.系统分析与协调[M].天津:天津大学出版社,2008. [22]仲伟俊,梅姝娥,黄超.国家创新体系与科技公共服务[M].北京:科学出版社,2015. [23]曾广容.系统的目的性[J].系统辩证学学报,1994 (4):36. [24]范冬萍.系统整体:秩序、方法与价值[J].系统辩证学学报,2002 (2):4-7. [25]陆勇,童鹰.从系统观整体性原则看科学技术学建设[J].系统科学学报,2008,16 (4):72-75. [26]POWELL W W,SMITH-DOERR K L.Interorganizational collaboration and the locus of innovation:networks of learning in biotechnology[J].Administrative science quarterly,1996,41 (1):116-145. [27]孙东川,林福永.谈谈系统的层次性与涌现性[C]// 中国系统工程学会.Well-off society strategies and systems engineering:proceedings of the 13th annual conference of system engineering society of China.2004:6. [28]佟瑞.系统涌现性视角的产业技术路线图核心竞争力研究[J].系统科学学报,2012,20 (3):58-61. [29]董伟,颜泽贤.知识创新系统的涌现特征和机理探析[J].科技管理研究,2007 (10):227-229. [30]BERTALANFFY V L.The theory of open systems in physics and biology[J].Science,1950,111 (2872):23-29. [31]张旺君.系统开放、反馈调节与渐进进化原理[J].系统科学学报,2018,26 (3):47-50+75. [32]ARRANZ N,ARROYABE M F,SCHUMANN M.The role of NPOs and international actors in the national innovation system:a network-based approach[J].Technological forecasting and social change,2020 (159):120183. [33]SZCZYGIELSKI K,GRABOWSKI W,PAMUKCU M T,et al.Does government support for private innovation matter?Firm-level evidence from two catching-up countries[J].Research policy,2017,46 (1):219-237. [34]刘戒骄.美国制造业复兴困境与启示:保护主义政策失灵的现实考察[J].北京工业大学学报 (社会科学版),2020,20 (5):12-22. [35]FLEMING L,GREENE H,LI G,et al.Government-funded research increasingly fuels innovation[J].Science,2019,364 (6446):1139-1141. [36]WOOLTHUIS R K,LANKHUIZEN M,GILSING V.A system failure framework for innovation policy design[J].Technovation,2005 (25):609-619. [37]CARLSSON B,JACOBSSON S.In search of useful public policies:key lessons and issues for policy makers[M].New York:Springer US,1997. [38]张华胜.美国国家制造业创新网络建设及管理模式[J].全球科技经济瞭望.2019,34 (1):15-25. [39]MOTOHASHI K,MURAMATSU S.Examining the university industry collaboration policy in Japan:patent analysis[J].Technology in society,2012,34 (2):149-162. [40]王玲.浅析日本国家创新体系改革新动向[J].世界科技研究与发展,2018,40 (6):571-583. [41]BLOCK F.Swimming against the current:the rise of a hidden developmental state in the United States[J].Politics & society,2008,36 (2):169-206. [42]MAZZUCATO M.The entrepreneurial state:debunking public vs.private sector myths[M].London:Anthem Press,2013. [43]ROBINSON D K R,MAZZUCATO M.The evolution of mission-oriented policies:exploring changing market creating policies in the US and European space sector[J].Research policy,2019,48 (4):936-948. [44]DELEIDI M,MAZZUCATO M.Directed innovation policies and the supermultiplier:an empirical assessment of mission-oriented policies in the US economy[J].Research policy,2021,50 (2),104151. [45]GASSMANN O.Opening up the innovation process:towards an agenda[J].R&D management,2006,36 (3):223-228. [46]KWON S,MOTOHASHI K.How institutional arrangements in the national innovation system affect industrial competitiveness:a study of Japan and the US with multiagent simulation[J].Technological forecasting and social change,2017 (115):221-235.
2022, 
