A Quantitative Study on China's PPP Policies:the Evolution and Change of the Collaboration Among Governance Institutions
Hu Wenbo1, Wang Ge1,2, Song Yu1, Huang Chen1, Wu Yuchao3
1. College of Public Administration,Huazhong Agricultural University,Wuhan 430070,China; 2. Antai College of Economics and Management,Shanghai Jiao Tong University,Shanghai 200030,China; 3. The First Company of China Eighth Engineering Division Ltd.,Jinan 250100,China
Abstract：To facilitate the development of PPP,a series of policies are issued intensively and the collaboration among governance institutions has been enhanced significantly.How to reveal the evolution of collaboration among governance institutions systematically is an important issue in promoting the development of public service.The evolution process of PPP policies consists of four stages,namely,preliminary exploration,strategic adjustment,steady improvement,and comprehensive development.This study employs social network analysis to reveal the characteristics of the overall network and different nodes,thereby showcasing the process and mechanism of the network evolution.The density of the network increases tortuously and the centrality decreases,the clustering coefficient increases incrementally,and the average path distance first decreases and then increases.The evolution of the network experiences three typologies (i.e.,center-edge type,loose type,and decentralized-coupled type),showing a diversified and balanced trend.In the stage of comprehensive development,the degree centrality and closeness centrality between adjacent sub-stages are significantly positively correlated,and the correlation coefficient first rises and then decreases.Therefore,PPP policies have entered into the incremental development and transformation period.
胡文伯, 王歌, 宋钰, 黄宸, 吴余超. 公私合作模式政策量化研究:治理机构合作关系的演化与变迁[J]. 中国科技论坛, 2021(12): 10-17.
Hu Wenbo, Wang Ge, Song Yu, Huang Chen, Wu Yuchao. A Quantitative Study on China's PPP Policies:the Evolution and Change of the Collaboration Among Governance Institutions. , 2021(12): 10-17.
[1]杜焱强,王亚星,陆万军.PPP模式下农村环境治理的多元主体何以共生?——基于演化博弈视角的研究[J].华中农业大学学报 (社会科学版),2019 (6):89-96+163-164. [2]肖萍,卢群.城市治理过程中公众参与问题研究——以政府特许经营PPP项目为对象[J].南昌大学学报 (人文社会科学版),2016,47 (6):89-94. [3]魏娜,范梓腾,孟庆国.中国互联网信息服务治理机构网络关系演化与变迁——基于政策文献的量化考察[J].公共管理学报,2019,16 (2):91-104+172-173. [4]董再平.中国PPP模式的内涵、实践和问题分析[J].理论月刊,2017 (2):129-134+178. [5]HOGWOOD B W,PETERS B G.The dynamics of policy change:policy succession[J].Policy sciences,1982,14 (3):225-245. [6]HECLO H.Modern social politics in Britain and Sweden:from relief to income maintenance[M].New Haven:Yale University Press,1974. [7]高小军,朱敏.多源流理论视域下欧盟终身学习政策变迁研究[J].比较教育研究,2020,42 (10):91-98. [8]王家庭,曹清峰.京津冀区域生态协同治理:由政府行为与市场机制引申[J].改革,2014 (5):116-123. [9]柯洪,王美华,杜亚灵.政策工具视角下PPP政策文本分析——基于2014—2017年PPP国家政策[J].情报杂志,2018,37 (11):81-88. [10]胡春艳,周付军.中国PPP政策工具选择及其选择模式研究——基于中央政策的文本分析[J].北京行政学院学报,2019 (4):45-55. [11]方俊智,李忻蔚.我国PPP政策与文献互动演化规律的计量分析[J].情报杂志,2019,38 (10):161-167. [12]王虎,王磊.民族地区社会治理的现实依据与逻辑基础[J].贵州民族研究,2016,37 (10):61-65. [13]HODGE G A,GREVE C.Public-private partnerships:an international performance review[J].Public administration review,2007,67 (3):545-558. [14]严玲,尹贻林,范道津.公共项目治理理论概念模型的建立[J].中国软科学,2004 (6):130-135. [15]PINTO J K.Project management,governance and the normalization of deviance[J].International journal of project management,2014,32 (3):376-387. [16]严强.政府间关系:体制与行政[J].江苏行政学院学报,2009 (1):103-108. [17]李欢欢,顾丽梅.垃圾分类政策试点扩散的逻辑分析——基于中国235个城市的实证研究[J].中国行政管理,2020 (8):81-87. [18]马续补,张潇宇,秦春秀,等.我国公共信息资源开放政策扩散特征的量化研究——以三大经济圈为例[J].信息资源管理学报,2020,10 (4):15-26. [19]刘军.整体网分析讲义:UCINET软件实用指南[M].上海:格致出版社,2009:1-2. [20]王歌,张安录,杨帆,等.土地科技创新的合作网络及热点演化研究——以国土资源科学技术奖为例[J].中国土地科学,2019,33 (6):104-112. [21]何清华,王歌.知识图谱视角下绿色低碳建筑研究动态[J].中国科技论坛,2015 (10):136-141. [22]SUN Y,CAO C.The evolving relations between government agencies of innovation policymaking in emerging economies:a policy network approach and its application to the Chinese case[J].Research policy,2018,47 (3):592-605. [23]余洋婷,吴水荣,孟贵,等.1949—2019年中国林业政策发布主体合作网络演化研究[J].林业经济,2020,42 (4):3-19. [24]于琦,常江毅,邰杨芳,等.我国卫生政策主体合作网络演化研究[J].中国卫生经济,2019,38 (8):5-11.
2021, 
