Does Commercialization of GM Staple Food Crops Affect China's Economic Security ——The Revelation Based on Comparative Analysis of China,the U.S.and India
Li Wanjun, Bao Yuze, Li Yanjun
College of Economics and Management,Huazhong Agricultural University,Wuhan 430070,China
Abstract：Based on the literature on the impact of commercialization of GM staple food crops on China's economic security,we used text analysis to extract the basic variables which may affect China's economic security due to implementing the commercialization of GM staple food crops,i.e.technology patent,enterprise strength,industrial dependence,auxiliary industries,international trade,pricing power,market demand,system guarantees and regulatory capabilities.We compared these variables with comparative advantage indexes and the factors of the source of competitive advantage in Poter's Diamonds Framework.We divided these variables into “incentive”factors and “guaranteed”factors.Then we make a comparative analysis in terms of these basic variables between China,the U.S.and India.We found that China is at a disadvantage compared with above two countries in many basic variables,especially in the “incentive”factors.Therefore,China has no incentive to promote the commercialization of GM staple food crops presently,and hastily implementing may bring some uncertainty to economic security.The main policy should be planning ahead and taking the path of independent R&D,and the comparative advantages and competitive advantages presented by the basic variables also vary from different crops.Therefore,we should use classification guidance to implement differentiated development.
李万君, 包玉泽, 李艳军. 转基因主粮作物商业化影响中国经济安全吗——基于对中美印比较分析的启示[J]. 中国科技论坛, 2022(11): 163-173.
Li Wanjun, Bao Yuze, Li Yanjun. Does Commercialization of GM Staple Food Crops Affect China's Economic Security ——The Revelation Based on Comparative Analysis of China,the U.S.and India. , 2022(11): 163-173.
[1]国际农业生物技术应用服务组织.2019年全球生物技术/转基因作物商业化发展态势[J].中国生物工程杂志,2021,41 (1):114-119. [2]雷家骕,陈亮辉.基于国民利益的国家经济安全及其评价[J].中国软科学,2012 (12):17-32. [3]PILLARISETTI J R,KYLIE R. Economic and environmental issues in international trade and production of genetically modified foods and crops and the WTO[J].Journal of economic integration,2004,19 (2):332-352. [4]HUANG J K,HU R F,ROZELLE S,et al.Genetically modified rice,yields,and pesticides:assessing farm-level productivity effects in China[J].Economic development and cultural change,2008,56 (2):241-263. [5]赵芝俊,孙炜琳,张社梅.转基因抗虫 (Bt)玉米商业化的经济效益预评价[J].农业经济问题,2010,31 (9):32-36. [6]GRAHAM B,PETER B.Key global economic and environmental impacts of genetically modified (GM)crop use 1996-2012[J].Journal of Huazhong agricultural university,2014,33 (6):17-23. [7]展进涛,唐若迪,谢锐.转基因水稻产业化的潜在动态影响——基于可计算一般均衡模型模拟的研究[J].农业经济问题,2015,36 (4):11-18. [8]乔方彬.转基因抗虫棉经济效益可持续性研究[J].中国科学:生命科学,2018,48 (12):1330-1342. [9]FALCK-ZEPEDA J,GRUERE G,SITHOLE N.Genetically modified crops in Africa:economic and policy lessons from countries south of the Sahara[M].Washington D.C.:International food policy research institute,2013. [10]童小溪.风险社会中的转基因主粮论争[J].探索与争鸣,2010 (12):20-22. [11]张宁宁,潘勇辉.种业跨国并购与我国种业应对策略的均衡分析[J].农业技术经济,2014 (2):57-67. [12]陈健鹏.转基因作物商业化:影响、挑战和应对——整体战略研究框架的构建和初步分析[J].中国软科学,2010 (6):1-14. [13]崔宁波,生世玉.美国转基因玉米产业化的生态及经济影响分析[J].世界农业,2020 (8):98-104. [14]CATACORA-VARGAS G,BINIMELIS R,MYHR A I,et al.Socio-economic research on genetically modified crops:a study of the literature[J].Agriculture and human values,2018,35 (2):489-513. [15]BALASSA B.Trade liberation and revealed comparative advantage[J].The Manchester school of economic and societal studies,1965,33 (2):99-123. [16]ABDUL K M A,ROBERT J R E.On the measurement of product quality in intra-industry trade[J].Review of world economics,2006,142 (3):476-495. [17]芮明杰.产业竞争力的 “新钻石模型”[J].社会科学,2006 (4):68-73. [18]林毅夫,李永军.比较优势、竞争优势与发展中国家的经济发展[J].管理世界,2003 (7):21-28. [19]吴建南,马亮,杨宇谦.中国地方政府创新的动因、特征与绩效——基于 “中国地方政府创新奖”的多案例文本分析[J].管理世界,2007 (8):43-51. [20]程杰.转基因主粮商业化:孰是孰非[J].中国农村科技,2010 (4):16-25. [21]芦骞.我国转基因主粮产业化的困难[J].中国粮食经济,2012 (6):25-27. [22]熊芙蓉.我国玉米进口价格变化研究[J].价格理论与实践,2012 (8):57-58. [23]蒋高明,李霄.试论转基因主粮产业安全与风险[J].工程研究-跨学科视野中的工程,2010,2 (2):112-119. [24]姚万军,吴晗.我国应否将主粮转基因技术产业化——基于一般均衡框架的经济学分析[J].南开学报 (哲学社会科学版),2014 (5):85-94. [25]王彦博,朱晓艳.上海市居民转基因食品认知与购买意愿研究[J].现代商业,2018 (2):14-15. [26]孙永立.农业农村部:粮食价格总体平稳 猪肉价格持续下行[J].中国食品工业,2021 (20):21-27. [27]傅龙波,钟甫宁,徐志刚.中国粮食进口的依赖性及其对粮食安全的影响[J].管理世界,2001 (3):135-140. [28]ÖZ B,UNSAL F,MOVASSAGHI H.Consumer attitudes toward genetically modified food in the United States:are Millennials different[J].Journal of transnational management,2017,23 (9):1-19. [29]郑志浩.信息对消费者行为的影响:以转基因大米为例[J].世界经济,2015,38 (9):144-165. [30]陆群峰.转基因作物产业化推广监管:政府失灵与公众监督[J].中国科技论坛,2014 (2):118-123. [31]胡旭,刘晓莉.我国转基因食品安全监管的制度完善[J].理论月刊,2017 (6):94-100. [32]徐家鹏,闫振宇.农民对转基因技术的认知及转基因主粮的潜在生产意愿分析——以湖北地区种粮农户为考察对象[J].中国科技论坛,2010 (11):142-148. [33]BUNING T D C,CLAAR D B,MARIETTE V A.NIMBY or how do the rural neighbours respond to genetically modified (GM)crops? An exploration of the structure of reactions by inhabitants in rural communities in The Netherlands to the commercial cultivation of GM crops in their community[J].Geoforum,2011,42 (3):349-361. [34]徐治立,刘柳.中国转基因作物产业化决策伦理共识路径探讨——基于互动满意人理念分析[J].中国科技论坛,2017 (5):137-143. [35]温铁军,高俊.重构宏观经济危机 “软着陆”的乡土基础[J].探索与争鸣,2016 (4):4-9. [36]李光泗,朱丽莉,孙文华.基于政府调控能力视角的中国粮食安全测度与评价[J].软科学,2011,25 (3):74-78. [37]朱满德,李辛一,程国强.综合性收入补贴对中国玉米全要素生产率的影响分析——基于省级面板数据的DEA-Tobit两阶段法[J].中国农村经济,2015 (11):4-14. [38]陈风波,刘晓丽,冯肖映.水稻生产补贴政策实施效果及农户的认知与评价——来自长江中下游水稻产区的调查[J].华南农业大学学报 (社会科学版),2011,10 (2):1-12. [39]高鸣.脱钩收入补贴对小麦生产率有影响吗——基于农户的微观证据[J].中国农村经济,2017 (11):47-61.
2022, 
