Research on Ethical Embeddedness in the Regulation of Artificial Intelligence for Medicine
Wang Chen1, Sun Qigui2, Xu Fei1
1. Department of Philosophy of Science and Technology;University of Science and Technology of China,Hefei 230026,China; 2. School of Public Affairs,University of Science and Technology of China,Hefei 230026,China
Abstract：Ethical value has become a necessary measurement element for the sustainable development of medical artificial intelligence.In previous studies,the possible ethical and moral problems in different application scenarios have been combed and analyzed in detail,and attempts have been made to put forward governance suggestions for different medical scenarios.However,in the face of the lack of ethical value in the transformation of intelligent medicine,there is little comprehensive research.This paper uses the theory of socio-technical transformation,based on the macro landscape and micro niche,to gain insight into the shortcomings of the current medical ethical governance of artificial intelligence.Taking the shaping path of the future intelligent medical society-technical system as the starting point,this paper believes that the social network dialogue mechanism,institutional innovation and social experiment are the feasible paths for embedding ethical values in the design of medical artificial intelligence,emphasizing the equal consultation of multiple stakeholders,the collaborative progress between multi-dimensional institutional norms and the practical feedback of social technology experiments are the necessary guarantee for the“science and technology for the good”of medical artificial intelligence.
汪琛, 孙启贵, 徐飞. 基于价值嵌入的医疗人工智能伦理规制研究[J]. 中国科技论坛, 2022(8): 172-180.
Wang Chen, Sun Qigui, Xu Fei. Research on Ethical Embeddedness in the Regulation of Artificial Intelligence for Medicine. , 2022(8): 172-180.
[1]ELLAHHAM S,ELLAHHAM N,SIMSEKLER M C E.Application of artificial intelligence in the health care safety context:opportunities and challenges[J].American journal of medical quality,2020,35(4):341-348. [2]KINKOROVA J,TOPOLCAN O.Biobanks in the era of big data:objectives,challenges,perspectives,and innovations for predictive,preventive,and personalised medicine[J].EPMA journal,2020,11(3):333-341. [3]RIGBY M J.Ethical dimensions of using artificial intelligence in health care[J].AMA journal of ethics,2019,21(2):121-124. [4]HAMET P,TREMBLAY J.Artificial intelligence in medicine[J].Metabolism:clinical and experimental,2017,69:S36-S40. [5]HASHIMOTO D A,ROSMAN G,RUS D,et al.Artificial intelligence in surgery:promises and perils[J].Annals of surgery,2018,268(1):70-76. [6]MORGENSTERN J D,ROSELLA L C,DALEY M J,et al.A fundamental qualitative descriptive study of the implications of artificial intelligence for public health[J].BMC public health,2021,21(1):1-14. [7]STARKE G,CLERCQ E D,ELGER B S.Towards a pragmatist dealing with algorithmic bias in medical machine learning[J].Medicine health care and philosophy,2021,24(3):341-349. [8]GOODING P,KARIOTIS T.Ethics and law in research on algorithmic and data-driven technology in mental health care:scoping review[J].JMIR mental health,2021,8(6):e24668. [9]URSIN F,TIMMERMANN C,STEGER F.Explicability of artificial intelligence in radiology:is a fifth bioethical principle conceptually necessary[J].Bioethics,2022,36(2):143-153. [10]FELDER R M.Coming to terms with the black box problem:how to justify AI systems in health care[J].Hastings center report,2021,51(4):38-45. [11]WANGMO T,LIPPS M,KRESSIG R W,et al.Ethical concerns with the use of intelligent assistive technology:findings from a qualitative study with professional stakeholders[J].BMC medical ethics,2019,20:98 [12]SAND M,DURÁN J M,JONGSMA K R.Responsibility beyond design:physicians' requirements for ethical medical AI[J].Bioethics,2022,26(2):162-169. [13]POEL I.Embedding values in artificial intelligence(AI)systems[J].Minds and machines,2020,30:385-409. [14]DURÁN J.Dissecting scientific explanation in AI(sXAI):a case for medicine and healthcare[J].Artificial intelligence,2021,297:103498. [15]UMBRELLO S,CAPASSO M,BALISTRERI M,et al.Value sensitive design to achieve the UN SDGs with AI:a case of elderly care robots[J].Minds and machine,2021,31(3):395-419. [16]GEELS F W,SCHWANEN T,SORRELL S R,et al.Reducing energy demand through low carbon innovation:a sociotechnical transitions perspective and thirteen research debates[J].Energy research & social science,2018,40:23-35. [17]GEELS F W,SOVACOOL B,SORRELL S.Of emergence,diffusion and impact[M]//JENKINS K E H,HOPKINS D.Transitions in energy efficiency and demand.Abingdon:Routledge,2019:27. [18]MCLAUGHLIN J,ROSEN P,SKINNER D,et al.Valuing technology:organisations,culture and change[M].London & New York:Routledge,1999:41-42. [19]孙启贵,汪琛,王加宇,等.医疗人工智能发展的社会-技术分析与启示[J].自然辩证法研究,2021,37(3):48-53. [20]GEELS F W.From sectoral systems of innovation to socio-technical systems:insights about dynamics and change from sociology and institutional theory[J].Research policy,2004,33(6):897-920. [21]SCHOT J,GEELS F W.Strategic niche management and sustainable innovation journeys:theory,findings,research agenda,and policy[J].Technology analysis & strategic management,2008,20(5):537-554. [22]VAYENA E,BLASIMME A,COHEN I G.Machine learning in medicine:addressing ethical challenges[J].Plos med,2018,15(11):1-4. [23]OBERMEYER Z,POWERS B,VOGELI C,et al.Dissecting racial bias in an algorithm used to manage the health of populations[J].Science,2019,366(6464):447-453. [24]KNOPPERS B M,THOROGOOD A M.Ethics and big data in health[J].Current opinion in systems biology,2017,4:53-57. [25]SHORTLIFFE E H,SEPÚLVEDA M J.Clinical decision support in the era of artificial intelligence[J].JAMA,2018,320(21):2199-2200. [26]布莱恩·阿瑟.技术的本质[M].曹东溟,王健,译.浙江:浙江人民出版社,2018:59. [27]任安波,叶斌.我国人工智能伦理教育的缺失及对策[J].科学与社会,2020,10(3):14-21. [28]刘伶俐,贺一墨,刘祥德.患者对人工智能医疗的认知及信任度调查[J].中国医学伦理学,2019,32(8):986-990. [29]MCDOUGALL R J.Computer knows best? The need for value-flexibility in medical AI[J].J med ethics,2019,45(3):156-160. [30]SIMON H A.The sciences of the artificial[M].Cambridge:MIT Press,2001:22. [31]陈凡,徐旭.当代人工智能伦理设计的困境和超越[J].华中科技大学学报(社会科学版),2020,34(5):1-7. [32]张寒,王锦刚.人工智能改变医学的理性权衡——基于MIT/MGH乳腺癌筛查人工智能系统的考察[J].自然辩证法研究,2021,37(1):40-46. [33]朱晶.复杂性哲学视角下的人工智能医学[J].哲学分析,2018,9(5):27-37,196-197. [34]MURPHY K,RUGGIERO E D,UPSHUR R,et al.Artificial intelligence for good health:a scoping review of the ethics literature[J].BMC medical ethics,2021,22:14. [35]TOPOL E.Deep medicine:how artificial intelligence can make healthcare human again[M].New York:Basic Books,2019:18. [36]DU S,XIE C.Paradoxes of artificial intelligence in consumer markets:ethical challenges and opportunities[J].Journal of business research,2021,129:961-974. [37]陈小平.人工智能中的封闭性和强封闭性——现有成果的能力边界、应用条件和伦理风险[J].智能系统学报,2020,15(1):114-120. [38]WALRAVE B,TALMAR M,PODOYNITSYNA K S,et al.A multi-level perspective on innovation ecosystems for path-breaking innovation[J].Technological forecasting & social change,2018,136:103-113. [39]UZZI B.Social structure and competition in interfirm networks:the paradox of embeddedness[J].Administrative science quarterly,1997,42(10):35-67. [40]高兆明.制度伦理与制度“善”[J].中国社会科学,2007(6):41-52,205. [41]赵清文.伦理与制度契合的理论误区与现实路径[J].宁夏社会科学,2017(6):5-10. [42]GEELS F W,RAVEN R.Non-linearity and expectations in niche-development trajectories:ups and downs in dutch biogas development(1973-2003)[J].Technology analysis & strategic management,2006,18(3-4):375-392. [43]苏竣,魏钰明,黄萃.社会实验:人工智能社会影响研究的新路径[J].中国软科学,2020(9):132-140. [44]苏竣,魏钰明,黄萃.基于场景生态的人工智能社会影响整合分析框架[J].科学学与科学技术管理,2021,42(5):3-19. [45]徐源.人工智能伦理的研究现状、应用困境与可计算探索[J].社会科学,2021(9):117-124. [46]CAWTHORNE D,WYNSBERGHE A.An ethical framework for the design,development,implementation,and assessment of drones used in public healthcare[J].Science and engineering ethics,2020,26:2867-2891.
2022, 
